Challenging the Popular Mantra

“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” is a saying we’ve all heard and perhaps even leaned on during tough times. It suggests resilience and the idea that adversity inherently fortifies us. But is this always true? While this mantra can be empowering, it’s essential to recognize that some struggles do more damage than growth. There are moments when trauma leaves scars rather than strength, and acknowledging this reality is key to genuine healing and self-growth.

---

When Struggles Leave Lasting Wounds

Not every challenge results in empowerment. Some experiences can fracture our sense of self, leaving wounds that don’t heal easily. During my early career, I faced significant setbacks that tested my limits. While I’d like to say I emerged stronger each time, the truth is that some periods left me feeling diminished and vulnerable.

Take, for instance, those who endure long-term stress or trauma. Instead of coming out stronger, they may find themselves grappling with anxiety, self-doubt, or a diminished sense of confidence. The pressure to “bounce back” can be overwhelming, creating a cycle where people feel guilty for not being “strong enough.” Recognizing that it’s okay to feel weaker after hardship is an important step in recovery.

The Real Impact of the “Strong Enough” Narrative

Society often romanticizes resilience, praising those who “push through” without acknowledging the toll it takes. This mindset can minimize genuine pain and hinder emotional growth. I remember reading about the renowned author and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel, who spoke openly about how trauma shaped his life. His experiences didn’t just make him “stronger”—they altered him fundamentally, leaving marks that no affirmation could erase.

Celebrities and Real-Life Stories of Vulnerability

Many celebrities, including athletes and artists, have shared how enduring difficult times did not immediately translate to strength. For example, mental health advocates like Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson have spoken about their struggles with depression despite their perceived resilience. He has shared candidly how facing mental health challenges required him to seek help and acknowledge his vulnerabilities. It was through therapy and opening up about his experiences that he found a path to healing—not through sheer willpower alone but through accepting that strength comes from acknowledging pain.

Another powerful example is singer Adele, who has been open about her battles with postpartum depression. She shared how this period in her life made her feel disconnected and overwhelmed, stating that pretending everything was fine only deepened her struggles. Through therapy, self-reflection, and leaning on loved ones, she was able to navigate her emotions. Adele’s journey highlights that recovery and transformation are often non-linear, requiring patience and self-compassion.

Emma Stone, known for her vibrant on-screen presence, has also been transparent about her lifelong battle with anxiety. She revealed that while her experiences with anxiety didn’t make her stronger in the immediate sense, they taught her the importance of seeking help, understanding her triggers, and practicing self-care. Stone credits therapy and coping strategies for helping her live alongside her anxiety rather than being defined by it.

These stories illustrate that true resilience is not just about enduring hardship but learning to adapt and grow from it in ways that acknowledge vulnerability.

Expanding on the Kintsugi Metaphor

The Japanese art of Kintsugi, where broken pottery is repaired with gold, serves as a profound metaphor for resilience. In kintsugi, the cracks and breaks in a piece are not hidden but highlighted, turning the object’s imperfections into something even more beautiful. This concept resonates deeply when applied to our own experiences. Just as the repaired pottery is valued for its unique flaws, so too can our personal struggles make us more resilient, but only when we embrace those fractures and integrate them into our story.

Kintsugi teaches that beauty and strength can come from acknowledging our pain and learning from it, rather than trying to pretend it never happened. The gold that mends the pottery is symbolic of the lessons, compassion, and growth that come from facing hardship head-on. This visual reminder can help us reframe our perception of resilience from something unyielding to something accepting and adaptive.

Reframing Strength: A Balanced Perspective

Rather than viewing resilience as an unwavering force, we should see it as a spectrum. Strength isn’t solely measured by how we “push through” but also by how we allow ourselves to rest, reflect, and seek help. Accepting that some events leave us changed—not always for the better—is part of the human experience.

Returning to the kintsugi metaphor, we must remind ourselves that it’s not the original state of the pottery that makes it valuable after repair—it’s the fact that it was broken and carefully mended. Embracing this mindset allows us to see our own growth through a lens of patience and self-compassion.

---

Tools for Navigating and Acknowledging the Aftermath

Instead of clinging to the idea that we must emerge stronger, we should focus on tools and practices that promote true healing:

a. Therapy and Counseling

Seeking professional support can help process complex emotions and trauma. Therapy provides a safe space to explore pain without judgment, allowing individuals to redefine what “strength” means in their context. Resources like the BetterHelp platform offer accessible online therapy options for those looking to start this journey.

b. Mindfulness and Meditation

Practicing mindfulness helps ground us in the present, offering solace from intrusive thoughts about past pain. Incorporating guided meditations from platforms such as Headspace or Calm can foster self-awareness and acceptance. These practices create moments to reflect and remind us that healing is an ongoing process.

c. Community Support

Engaging with support groups or trusted friends can lighten the burden. Sharing experiences reminds us that we are not alone and that being vulnerable in front of others can be healing in itself. For example, joining online communities like those on Reddit’s r/Anxiety or local support groups can create a network of empathy and understanding.

Practical Steps for Embracing Authentic Growth

To help navigate challenging experiences, consider these actionable steps:

• Acknowledge Your Feelings: It’s okay to admit when you feel weakened by adversity. Denying emotions only compounds the pain. Consider reading The Body Keeps the Score by Dr. Bessel van der Kolk to understand how trauma impacts us and the importance of acknowledgment.
  
• Redefine Strength: Strength can mean taking time to heal, asking for help, or learning to say “no.” Embrace activities like yoga or tai chi that promote gentle self-care and connection with your body.
  
• Journaling: Reflect on how certain experiences have impacted you, both positively and negatively. Writing can be therapeutic and insightful. Consider prompts such as, “What did I learn from this experience?” or “How can I show myself compassion today?”
  
• Educate Yourself: Read books or listen to podcasts that explore the complexities of resilience. Option B by Sheryl Sandberg and Adam Grant discusses overcoming life’s toughest challenges and reframing grief and adversity.
  
• Connect with Nature: Spend time outdoors to ground yourself and find moments of peace. Nature walks or mindful breathing exercises in a park can help restore a sense of calm and perspective.
  

---

Strength Isn’t Always About Winning

“What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” is a powerful statement, but it’s not universally true. Strength is not a one-size-fits-all result of adversity. Sometimes, it’s okay to acknowledge that challenges leave us scarred and vulnerable. True growth comes from recognizing our limits, seeking help, and learning to rebuild with compassion.